Skip to main content

Designers including Calvin Klein file amicus brief supporting Apple in patent case with Samsung

how to watch apple september 12 event 2017 tim cook
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Remember the Apple vs. Samsung case from 2011? It’s still going on, and now more than 100 industrial design professionals and educators have submitted an amicus brief in support of Apple.

For a quick refresher, Apple sued the South Korean giant back in 2011 claiming that Samsung infringed on patented designs and technology utilized in the iPhone. Samsung was ordered to pay $930 million to Apple, but that amount was later reduced by about $382 million by an appeals court. In December 2015, Samsung was ordered to pay $548 million to Apple along with an additional $180 million for “supplemental damages for continued infringement, plus interest.”

In February 2016, an appeals court overturned a separate 2014 ruling that ordered Samsung to pay $119.6 million to Apple for infringing on smartphone patents, awarding a victory to the Korean company. The court even found that Apple infringed on one of Samsung’s patents, and Apple was ordered to pay $158,400. While it was a loss, that amount is chump change for the Cupertino company.

In July 2015, major tech companies including Google, HP, Facebook, Ebay, Dell and more filed an amicus brief supporting Samsung. An amicus brief is a letter from parties that have an interest in the case, and it offers unsolicited information to the court. A year later in July 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to take the case, and the first oral arguments will be heard on Oct. 10.

The date looms closer, and now we have more than a hundred designers and educators undersigned to another amicus brief — but this time, it’s in support of Apple. The undersigned are impressive as they have provided product design services to companies such as Apple, AT&T, Calvin Klein, Coca-Cola, Ford, General Electric, General Motors, HP, Google, IBM, the New York Stock Exchange, NASA, Samsung itself, and more.

It also features names such as Raymond Riley, executive creative director at Microsoft; Bruce Claxton, the former senior director of design at Motorola Solutions; Calvin Klein, the founder of the fashion brand; Sohrab Vossoughi, a former senior industrial designer at HP; and many others.

The point the Supreme Court will decide is whether or not design patent damages should only be calculated by determining lost profits relating to the component that infringes on a patent, or relating to the entire device. Samsung argues for the former interpretation, and claims $399 million of the $548 million it was ordered to pay — which was initially awarded for infringing the design of the iPhone’s round corners, bezels, and more — is excessive.

The designers and educators believe Apple should be compensated with Samsung’s total profits, because a copied design can mean a lost sale.

“When a manufacturer copies the design of a successful product, it captures the consumer’s understanding of what the product does and what the product means,” according to the brief. “Moreover, copying of a design also allows the copier to enter the marketplace on the back of the brand attributes built by the patent holder — who has expended vast sums and effort in design, development, quality standards, marketing, sales, and product promotion.”

Samsung responded to our request for comment. “We have received overwhelming support for overturning the ruling in favor of Apple, including from leading patent experts, numerous concerned companies, and the U.S. government,” a Samsung spokesperson told Digital Trends. “If left uncorrected, the Appeals court’s ruling could lead to diminished innovation, pave the way for design troll patent litigation and negatively impact the economy and consumers.”

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
Apple iPhone 11 Pro Max vs. Samsung Galaxy Note 10 Plus
A hand holds an Apple iPhone 11 Pro Max showing apps on the screen.

The iPhone 11 Pro Max offered the latest and greatest features in a sleek design when it was launched in 2019. Even if it wasn't a major upgrade over the previous-generation iPhone XS Max, it still pushed the envelope further than any other Apple smartphone had done up until that point in time. But 2019 also delivered other high-tech -- and big -- smartphones, such as the Samsung Galaxy Note 10 Plus, which also came with a ton of awesome features.

Which of the two devices is better? Is there even a clear winner? We put the iPhone 11 Pro Max and the Samsung Galaxy Note 10 Plus head to head to find out.
Specs

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S21 vs. iPhone 12: Can Samsung take a bite of Apple?
samsung galaxy s21 preview first impressions all colors 3

Samsung has released the Samsung Galaxy S21, the successor to last year's Galaxy S20. It improves on its predecessor in several key areas, introducing improved software, a refreshed design, 5G as standard, and the latest Qualcomm Snapdragon 888 processor. It certainly looks like the kind of smartphone you'd expect to encounter in 2021, but it still has competition as the latest and greatest flagship to buy.

Chief among its competitors is the iPhone 12, Apple's latest showcase for its smartphone tech and wizardry. Like the S21, the iPhone 12 improves on the Apple phones that came before it, providing 5G as standard, a new high-powered processor, and an enhanced camera system. However, we need to find out which one is best for you. To do this, we compare the two phones across several categories, which together should help you decide which is worthier of your money.
Specs

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus vs. iPhone 12 Pro: Go Plus or Pro?
Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus

If you've been excitedly waiting for the new Samsung Galaxy S21 range, wait no longer! These new flagship handsets are now available for purchase. But if you've got your eye on both the iPhone 12 Pro and the Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus, how do you decide which to buy? Choosing between these two phones isn't as easy as it looks -- but we're here to help. We've compared these two phones across six core categories, from display to performance, and picked a clear winner. Which one should you buy? Keep reading, and you'll find out.

Specs

Read more