Skip to main content

Apple loses its patent battle against VirnetX, faces over $300 million in damages

apple store logo
cchana/Flickr
Apple’s arch nemesis for the time being is not Samsung or another smartphone maker — it’s VirnetX, a company most of us probably haven’t even heard of. It’s a firm founded by ex-employees of government contractor SAIC Inc., and is responsible for producing the technology that allows for secure communications. And according to VirnetX, that technology is being used by Apple in applications like FaceTime without proper permissions. Now a federal jury in Texas has ordered Apple to pay over $302 million worth of damages.

It’s the latest in a patent saga that first began in 2010. VirnetX first filed a lawsuit in the Eastern District of Texas federal court, and said that four of its patents for secure networks had been infringed upon. Two years later, a jury ruled in the Nevada-based company’s favor, awarding it $368.2 million. But then, an appeals court partially overturned that decision, citing problems with how the original judge told jurors to calculate damages owed.

Soon thereafter, VirnetX combined two lawsuits, and in February another jury awarded the company an impressive sum of $625.6 million — one of the largest payouts ever ordered in an American patent case. This result was also ruled null and void, which leads us to present day. And on Friday, it looks like VirnetX was given the last laugh, to the tune of $302.4 million.

Apple spokeswoman Rachel Tulley did not comment on the latest proceedings, and it looks like the news could get even worse for the Cupertino company. Further court proceedings are yet to take place, which will determine whether or not Apple “willfully infringed the patents.” If a judge rules that the company did do so, the damages could be even greater. Worse still, Apple is involved in another lawsuit with VirnetX; this one not over FaceTime, but over iMessage and some other Apple security features.

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
How to increase your internet speed in 7 easy steps
Man working at a desk at home.

Nothing is more frustrating than having to contend with a slow internet connection. Fortunately, though, there are some things you can do to improve matters. Before you reach for your phone to upgrade your internet plan, give these 7 tips a try:

Reset your router
Manage your Wi-Fi channels
Remove signal-hogging devices from your network
Use an Ethernet connection
'Flush' your DNS
Switch to a faster browser
Add an extension to manage your cache

Read more
The 18 best VPN services for 2024, reviewed by experts
best VPN services

These days more and more of our daily lives and everyday tasks are conducted online. Which means that it only becomes increasingly imperative that you prioritize ensuring that your financial and personal information is protected from cybercriminals. Protecting yourself from identity theft or even hackers can seem daunting, but it doesn't have to be. Take it one step at a time.

And your first step can be something as simple as using a virtual private network (VPN). The good news is that a reliable VPN is one of the easiest, cheapest, and most effective ways to safeguard your online activities from unwanted network intruders.

Read more
What are mouse jigglers, and can they keep statuses active?
Undetectable Mouse Mover at a computer.

It makes sense that mouse jigglers have gained prominence alongside the recent rise in jobs becoming remote positions. If more workers are working from home and away from employers' direct supervision, employers are going to try to find new ways to supervise their remote employees. And those employees are going to push back against being monitored by their employers. Which is how you end up with products like mouse jigglers becoming popular.

This odd little tech solution is being used to thwart some types of micromanagement and help employees manage time on their own terms, among other solutions. But do mouse jigglers work? Are jigglers allowed in the workplace? Here’s everything you should know.
What are mouse jigglers?

Read more