Best Buy, Samsung, Others Hit With GPL Lawsuit

By Geoff Duncan December 15, 2009

Samsung Luxia 8500 Series LED LCD HDTV — Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Freedom Law Center has filed suit against consumer electronics Best Buy, Samsung, Westinghouse, and eleven other consumer electronics companies for selling products containing BusyBox, a widely used Linux utility library that’s available for use under the GNU General Public License (GPL) version 2. BusyBox has a long, solid history for providing functionality to consumer electronics and other devices using embedded Linux operating systems, and under the terms of the GPL anyone can use, modify, and distribute BusyBox for free as long as they distribute the source code to customers, with any of their changes. The Software Freedom Law Center alleges that more than 20 products from these 14 manufacturers have failed to meet their obligations under the GPL: they’re including BusyBox, but they arent’ abiding my the minimal requirements of the GPL to distribute source code.

“We try very hard to resolve these types of issues privately with companies, as we always prefer cooperation,” said SFLC counsel Aaron Williamson, in a statement. “We brought this suit as a last resort after each of these defendants ignored us or failed to meaningfully respond to our requests that they release the source code”.

The new suit isn’t the first time major companies have been taken to court for rolling BusyBox into their products without distributing source code: previous defendants include Monsoon, Xterasys, Cisco, and Verizon. All those cases have been settled, with the companies agreeing to distribute source code.

The 14 companies named in the lawsuit are Best Buy, Samsung, Westinghouse, JVC, Western Digital, Bosch, Phoebe Micro, Humax, Comtrend, Dobbs-Stanford, Versa Technology, Zyxel, Astac, and GCI Technologies. Nearly 20 products are alleged to contain BusyBox in violation of the GPL license, including Best Buy’s Insignia Blu-ray DVD Player, Westinghouse’s 52-inch LCD TV, and Samsung HDTVs.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Samsung

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Computing

Best Buy dropped the price of this HP Envy laptop from $920 to $552

The HP Envy x360 15.6 2023 tent view.

For those who are planning to buy a laptop for work or school, you may want to check out 2-in-1 laptop deals so that you can get more versatility from your new device. We highly recommend the HP Envy x360, which is on sale from Best Buy with a $368 discount that pulls its price down to $552 from $920 originally. If you're interested in taking advantage of this offer, you're going to have be quick in completing your purchase because we're not sure if it will still be available tomorrow.

Why you should buy the HP Envy x360 2-in-1 laptop
A 2-in-1 laptop combines the convenience of a tablet's touchscreen and the utility of a laptop's keyboard, according to our laptop buying guide. These are the benefits of the HP Envy x360, which can easily transform between tablet mode and laptop mode through the 360-degree hinges that attach its body to its 15.6-inch display with Full HD resolution. You also have the option of going into tent mode when you're giving presentations or when you want to watch streaming shows without getting distracted by the keyboard.

Computing

8 best Chromebooks for 2024: the best for every budget

Chromebooks might have a hard time competing with Windows laptops and MacBooks, but that doesn't mean they don't have their place. We've reviewed hundreds of laptops over the years, testing for important qualities like performance, battery life, and display quality — and we've found that Chromebooks consistently excel at performance and reliability.

You can find Chromebooks from Google, HP, Lenovo, Acer, and many other branss, and we've dug through them to put together this roundup of the best Chromebooks on the market. They're incredibly accessible devices, and for the right person, a Chromebook can be the best laptop in terms of value.

Computing

This MSI ‘starter’ gaming laptop is discounted to $550 at Best Buy

The MSI GF63 gaming laptop against a white background.

While some of the best gaming laptops can cost thousands of dollars, you don't necessarily have to pay an arm and a leg to get yourself one. In fact, there are some solid options for entry-level gaming laptops that are very budget-friendly, like the MSI THIN GF63. While it's not that powerful, it does have a great discount from Best Buy that brings it down to $550 from the usual $700, which saves you $150 in the process.

Why you should buy the MSI Thin GF63
One of the most important parts of any gaming laptop is the GPU, and in this case, the MSI Thin GF63 comes with a slightly older GPU, the RTX 2050, which is admittedly an older card, but if you're not expected to play the latest AAA, that's not an issue. As an older card, you can expect something along the lines of medium settings at 1080p for older titles and some free-to-play games, so it's a good starter option to get you going. The screen is a solid 15.6 inches with an FHD resolution, and it even has a 144Hz refresh rate, although that's going to be difficult to hit even with graphical compromises.