Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Computing
  3. News

Boston University files patent suit against Apple, wants to ban iPhone, MacBook sales

By
Tim Cook Apple Court
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Another week, another instance of someone or some company seeking legal action against Apple – Apple and Nokia, Apple and HTC, and in one instance, a Apple and a Chinese animation studio, to name a few. Today, Apple is once again the defendant. This time, however it’s going up against Boston University in a patent infringement battle.

According to the Boston Herald, Apple infringed on a patent (Number US 5686738 A to be exact) owned by Boston University. The patent, granted in 1997, pertains to the creation of thin gallium nitride film semiconductors. The complaint, filed yesterday in the U.S. District Court of Massachusetts, says that a part used in the iPhone, iPad, and MacBook Air was patented by BU professor Theodore Moustakas. According to the complaint, several of Apple’s products, including the iPhone 5, iPad, and MacBook Air include a gallium nitride thin film semiconductor device claimed by the’738 patent, which BU says infringes one or more of the patent’s claims .

Recommended Videos

BU also said that Apple’s “acts of infringement have caused and will continue to cause substantial and irreparable damage to the University.” The institution is seeking damages from Apple, claiming that it wants Apple to tally up all of the profits it received from using BU’s technology, and then pay a share of the money to the institution – plus interest. The Boston Herald quotes tech analyst Roger Kay of Endpoint Technologies Associates as saying a successful verdict could see upwards of $75 million for BU. That’s just one analyst’s opinion, though, so take it with a grain of salt.

Apple isn’t the first company BU has gone after with this claim, however. BU filed the same complaint against Amazon and Samsung. The patent expires at the end of next year, so it’ll be interesting to see what happens with BU and the the trifecta of tech giants it’s up against.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Russ Boswell
Russ Boswell
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Russ Boswell is an aspiring video game and technology journalist from Colorado. He's been an avid gamer since he was old…
There’s great news if you want to buy Apple’s 15-inch MacBook Air
Apple's John Ternus stands next to an image of the 15-inch MacBook Air at Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June 2023.

When Apple launched the 15-inch MacBook Air at its Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC), it seemed like there wasn’t too much separating it from its 13-inch sibling. Yet a new set of tests has shown that the larger model pulls ahead in some key ways, making it a much more attractive purchase if you want maximum performance in a slimline laptop.

The testing was conducted by YouTuber Max Tech, who pitted the 15-inch MacBook Air against Apple’s smaller 13-inch version. Both laptops had the M2 chip and 256GB of storage, so you might think the only difference would be found in the size of the displays. Yet that’s not how the testing played out at all.

Read more
I don’t want a touchscreen MacBook, but this feature could convince me
A person typing on a MacBook Pro while sat on a wooden bench.

Rumors that Apple is making a touchscreen Mac are about as old as the Steve Jobs adage that touchscreen laptops suck and make your arm ache. But a fresh patent shows Apple is still working on the idea -- and this time the company might have finally perfected it.

As spotted by Patently Apple, the patent describes how a touchscreen Mac could incorporate haptic feedback into its display. That means you could get small tactile taps every time you press on the screen, which would subtly let you know that your actions have been recognized.

Read more
Apple’s next MacBooks and iPads could be in serious trouble
The MacBook Pro open on a wooden table.

Hype has been growing for Apple’s upcoming M3 chips, which are expected to splash down in a slate of Macs and iPads later this year. Yet one leaker has come along to spoil the party and has claimed that we won’t see anything of the sort until 2024.

That idea comes from Twitter leaker Revegnus, who tweeted that there would be “No M3 Mac or iPad for this year.” That will be disappointing news to anyone looking forward to laying their hands on the latest and greatest Apple silicon chips in the coming months.

Read more