Apple Sued for Monopolistic Practices

By Nick Mokey November 7, 2007

Apple Sued for Monopolistic Practices

Apple’s legal woes seemingly never end. If they aren’t being sued over hearing loss, touch screen patents, or the iPhone’s battery life, it’s something else entirely. The latest legal complaint: iTunes and the iPod allegedly constitute a monopoly.

According to AppleInsider, Florida resident Frederick Black filed a class action lawsuit against Apple back in August, alleging that the content restrictions on both iPods and music downloaded from iTunes violate Florida’s antitrust and fair trade laws. The problem lies in the iPod’s nonexistent support for downloaded music from other vendors, and in iTunes’ inability to transfer paid-for music to players that aren’t iPods.

Black’s attorneys wrote in the complaint that Apple “…by controlling such a large part of the portable digital media player market, the online music market and the online video market, maintains sufficient economic power in these markets to control consumer pricing in these markets, which has resulted in consumers paying higher prices.”

Black seeks damages of around $15,000, treble damages (a magnification of damages, used by courts as a punishment), and attorney fees.

Editors' Recommendations

Managing Editor

As Digital Trends’ Managing Editor, Nick Mokey oversees an editorial team delivering definitive reviews, enlightening…

Mobile

Wow! Walmart just dropped the price of this Apple Watch to $189

The front of the Apple Watch SE 2.

The Apple Watch is a fantastic piece of technology, but unfortunately its latest releases are pretty expensive. If you're fine with an older version of the wearable device, you may want to take advantage of Walmart's $60 discount for the GPS, 40mm model of the second-generation Apple Watch SE. From its original price of $249, it's down to a more affordable $189, and you won't be missing out on a lot of features. It's highly recommended that you make the purchase within the day, if possible, as tomorrow may already be too late to shop this offer.

Why you should buy the Apple Watch SE 2
The second-generation Apple Watch SE is featured in our list of the best smartwatches as the best budget smartwatch for the iPhone because you'll be able to access most of the features of Apple's wearable device at a fraction of the price of the flagship models. Its fitness-tracking features are comprehensive but simple to use, and it's comfortable to wear the whole day so you can maximize its battery life of up to two days on a single carge.

Mobile

The 45mm model of the Apple Watch Series 9 is $100 off right now

Post-walk fitness data on the Apple Watch Series 9.

There are some fantastic Apple Watch deals going on right now as part of the Memorial Day sales with $100 of the Apple Watch Series 9 at Best Buy. It usually costs $429 but right now, you can buy one for just $329. That’s for the Apple Watch Series 9 45mm Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Loop but you can also save $70 and get the watch with a for $329 if you’d prefer. Keen to learn more about the Apple Watch Series 9? Let’s take a look.

Why you should buy the Apple Watch Series 9
The Apple Watch Series 9 is one of the best smartwatches around if you own an iPhone. It’s the perfect assist to place on your wrist. It has a powerful S9 chip which ensures that you can switch between apps super fast without any issue. It also has a gorgeous and superbright always-on display so that you can clearly see what you’re doing.

Mobile

Apple’s next iPad mini could steal this iPad Pro feature

An iPad Mini 2021 displaying the homescreen with a number of apps.

Earlier this month, Apple introduced the iPad Pro (2024) and iPad Air (2024). This fall, Apple will likely update the original iPad, which was last updated in 2022.

But what about the often-overlooked iPad mini, whose current version is actually a year older? We may be waiting a while longer for new iPad mini hardware, but when it does finally arrive, it should be well worth the wait.