Skip to main content

Finally! Porsche 918 and McLaren P1 duke it out, with Laguna Seca as their battleground

2015 McLaren P1 vs. 2015 Porsche 918 Spyder! - Head 2 Head Ep. 64
The latest season of Top Gear was promising a showdown between the top three supercars on the roads today; the Porsche 918, Ferrari LaFerrari, and the McLaren P1. While its future was in turmoil last month, Motor Trend attempted to give this endeavor a shot on its own, lining up all three cars to make an appearance at the famous Mazda Laguna Seca race track. We talked about this before, but MT has now uploaded video of the cars that showed up duking it out.

If you didn’t catch the story before, the MT team lined up the McLaren P1 and Porsche 918 for the exercise without issue. They had a La Ferrari owner agree to its use, but Ferrari said “no” to its use for hot laps and data acquisition. While that put a little damper on the affairs, it’s still not going to spoil having two hypercars on hand for pro racer Randy Pobst to throttle them on the track.

Porsche 918 Spyder
Image used with permission by copyright holder

To start, Pobst sets off in the Porsche 918 and is immediately thrilled by how the 4.6-liter V8 delivers 608 horsepower to the rear wheels as well as the 279 hp sent to the front by the hybrid electric motor. As much as Pobst praises the all-wheel drive of the 918, he’s aware of the P1’s lightness.

When it comes to the McLaren, the P1’s power plant generates a total of 908 horsepower due to a 3.8-liter twin turbo V8 working in tandem with its own electric motor. One of the main differences in this vehicle is that all that power goes straight to the rear wheels. It makes it wilder than the 918, but will its lightness and power be enough to beat the control of the Porsche?

McLaren P1
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Much to the surprise of many, the Porsche 918 came out on top, with a 01:29.89 lap time. Try as it might, the McLaren can’t set a time faster than the 01:30.71 run it laid down.

It goes to show that though both cars have taken the same approach to power, they’ve done so in radically different ways. The end result in cars that constantly trump each other back in forth in different areas, but still manage to be fairly equal. The battle for hypercar supremacy carries on, but this is one significant notch on Porsche’s belt.

Editors' Recommendations

Alexander Kalogianni
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Alex K is an automotive writer based in New York. When not at his keyboard or behind the wheel of a car, Alex spends a lot of…
Mercedes-Benz G580 first drive: old-school off-roader goes electric
2025 Mercedes-Benz G580 from three quarter view.

American car buyers mostly know Mercedes-Benz as a luxury brand. But for decades, the automaker has also produced the tough, rugged G-Class (also known as the Geländewagen or G-Wagen), an SUV not afraid to get its leather upholstery muddy. And now, this iconic Mercedes is going electric.

The 2025 Mercedes-Benz G580 with EQ Technology — the final name of the SUV previously known as the EQG — isn’t the first electric off-roader. The Rivian R1S and R1T and GMC Hummer EV have proven that electric powertrains and off-roading are a great combination. But the electric G-Wagen is different because it’s based on an internal-combustion model — and a very traditional one at that.

Read more
Honda believes hydrogen semi trucks will make the case for fuel cells
Honda hydrogen fuel-cell semi truck.

Honda remains committed to hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles, but the market for those vehicles remains limited. So Honda is looking at other uses for fuel cells -- including commercial trucks.

To show how that could work, Honda converted a semi truck to fuel-cell power, replacing its diesel engine with three fuel-cell modules. Together, the three modules produce a combined 321 horsepower, and can propel the truck to a top speed of 70 mph. There's enough onboard hydrogen storage capacity for a 400-mile range with a full load, Honda claims.

Read more
Mercedes-Benz G580 vs Rivian R2: Is the much cheaper Rivian actually better?
2025 Mercedes-Benz G580 from three quarter view.

Mercedes-Benz has finally taken the wraps off of the new "Mercedes-Benz G580 with EQ Technology." Yeah, it's a mouthful, but it's basically a new electric G-Wagon. It looks a lot like the G-Wagon you know and love, but with an electric powertrain and a battery. It's not the only electric SUV out there, however, and there are some great ones -- like the Rivian R2.

Both the Mercedes G580 and the Rivian R2 have a lot going for them, but they also approach the electric SUV slightly differently. Is one better than the other? I put the two head-to-head to find out.
Design
The approach that the two vehicles take to design is quite different -- and you might like one better than the other.

Read more