Skip to main content

When does a toot become a honk? The big question pondered by Google’s self-driving team

Google Self-Driving Car
Image used with permission by copyright holder
When does a toot turn into a honk? And when does a honk become a blare, or even an all-out blast? It’s profound questions like these that are currently being pondered by Google’s self-driving team as it works on creating effective algorithms to control the vehicle’s horn.

In the future, when all cars are self-driving, the only need for a honk will presumably be to alert distracted pedestrians and cyclists. But until that day comes, self-driving cars will also have to continue looking out for careless human drivers, too.

‘Polite’ honking

“Our self-driving cars aim to be polite, considerate, and only honk when it makes driving safer for everyone,” the Mountain View company said in its latest monthly report on its driverless car project.

That’s really good to know, as the last thing you’d want is your self-driving car to start honking belligerently at other drivers, who, in a worst-case scenario, may wish to discuss the situation with the aid of a baseball bat.

The excuse, “It wasn’t me, it was the car,” may not go down too well with someone with rage in their eyes, and anyway, would you really want to shift the blame onto your beloved vehicle with all its snazzy, not to say very expensive, self-driving technology?

To reduce the chances of annoying a driver, Google said it’s trying to teach its vehicle to sound its horn “like a patient, seasoned driver” – rather than an irritable, impetuous, stressed-out one.

“Our self-driving software is designed to recognize when honking may help alert other drivers to our presence – for example, when a driver begins swerving into our lane or backing out of a blind driveway,” Google explains in its report.

During early testing, the horn would only sound inside the vehicle “so we wouldn’t confuse others on the road with a wayward beep.” Each time it sounded, the car’s test driver recorded whether the beep was appropriate and then passed the data to engineers back at base so they could set about improving that all-important honking algorithm.

Honing the honking

After much work, the team has now managed to hone the honking to such a degree that the horn now sounds off in different ways according to a particular situation. So, “if another vehicle is slowly reversing towards us, we might sound two short, quieter pips as a friendly heads-up to let the driver know we’re behind. However, if there’s a situation that requires more urgency, we’ll use one loud sustained honk.”

Considering its importance, honking has clearly been an underreported feature of self-driving cars, and one that, at Google at least, has been receiving much attention.

While the company reports self-driving accidents on a monthly basis, it’d also be interesting to hear about examples where a gentle toot or rhapsodic hoot has helped it to avoid a collision. Or caused a driver to get out with a baseball bat.

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
The future of transportation: Self-driving cars? Try self-driving everything
GM electric flying taxi

Technology is reshaping every aspect of our lives. Once a week in The Future Of, we examine innovations in important fields, from farming to transportation, and what they will mean in the years and decades to come. 

Stroll around any CES (virtual or otherwise) in the last decade and it’s impossible to miss all the feels the tech industry has for transportation, self-driving cars in particular. Every major technology company has its fingers in cars, from the infotainment systems powered by Google and Apple to the operating systems driven by Blackberry and Linux to the components and circuits that make up the car itself, built by Qualcomm and Nvidia and NXP and a dozen more. (And don't get me started about this Apple Car nonsense.)

Read more
From Paris to NYC, Mobileye will bring self-driving cars to metropolises
A self-driving vehicle from Mobileye's autonomous test fleet navigates the streets of Detroit. (Credit: Mobileye, an Intel Company)

A Tesla in Autopilot mode can ply the highways of Northern California without issue, but when it comes to congested cities packed with erratic vehicle traffic, bikes, and pedestrians, cameras don’t always cut it. Or they didn’t, anyway. After years of testing, Intel-owned Mobileye intends to embrace the madness of the metropolis by rolling out self-driving cars in cities across the world.

On Monday, the first day of CES 2021, the company announced that Tokyo, Shanghai, Paris, Detroit, and New York City will all see fleets of Mobileye-powered vehicles rolled out in early 2021, if all goes well (regulatory issues are still being ironed out in NYC).

Read more
Waymo ditches the term ‘self-driving’ in apparent dig at Tesla
waymo takes its self driving cars to florida for testing in heavy rain

Autonomous car company Waymo says it will stop using the term “self-driving” in a move that many will see as a swipe at Tesla.

Alphabet-owned Waymo said that starting this year it will refer to its driving technology as “fully autonomous.”

Read more