Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Computing

Apple Draws Ire Pushing Safari to Windows

By
Apple Draws Ire Pushing Safari to Windows

Apple has been shipping its own Web browser Safari with Mac OS X for several years now, and announced a version Safari for Windows a year ago. Safari represents a healthy share of the Macintosh browser market, but in terms of the overall Internet Safari is still in the single digits in terms of browser share. So no one was truly surprised that Apple would attempt to leverage the near ubiquity of its QuickTime and iTunes software as a way to introduce Windows users to other Apple applications: what surprises people is that Apple is using the updating capability to push new applications to those users by default.

Windows users who have QuickTime and/or iTunes installed are no doubt familiar with Apple’s Software Update utility, which periodically informs users when updates and patched versions of the software are available. Online update utilities are important components for operating systems and network-accessible software, giving vendors a simple way for users to update security patches and bug fixes. However, with the recently released Safari 3.1, the browser has turned up as an new component in Apple’s Software Update utility, and it is set to download by default. The result is that if users go along with Apple’s recommended software update, they get an entirely new application—unrelated to Apple software they already have installed—as part of the update.

Recommended Videos

The Safari 3.1 install is also enabled by default on Mac OS X systems; however, Safari ships as a default application with Mac OS X. Similarly, Windows users who already have Safari installed will see version 3.1 show up as an automatically-enabled update.

“What Apple is doing now with their Apple Software Update on Windows is wrong,” wrote Mozilla head John Lilly in his blog. “It’s wrong because it undermines the trust that we’re all trying to build with users. Because it means that an update isn’t just an update, but is maybe something more. Because it ultimately undermines the safety of users on the Web by eroding that relationship.”

Many industry watchers have opined that it makes sense for Apple to promote Safari 3.1 to Windows Users via Software Update, but criticize the company for making the download enabled by default, arguing a better option would have been to have the download disabled by default, or somehow distinguished as a new application rather than an update to existing software. (Some have noted Software Update may lack this sort of functionality.)

Others argue Apple’s move is about browser share and money, and Mozilla’s grousing about the move has more to do with revenue earned via Google’s prominent placement as the default search engine for Mozilla than Apple’s distribution tactics. Firefox earns the vast majority of its revenue from Google searches conducted via Firefox’s search box: Safari also has Google set as its default search engine, and a growing number of Windows users converting to Safari could mean declining revenues for Firefox, if those users come at Firefox’s expense rather than Internet Explorer’s. After all, Mozilla doesn’t have cash cows like well-established iPod and Macintosh businesses to rely on if its search revenue starts to dry up.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Geoff Duncan
Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Some updates coming to macOS 15 aren’t just about AI
Apple's 15-inch MacBook Air on a desk, with macOS Sonoma running on its display.

Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) is coming up soon, and everyone's expecting a huge announcement around AI. But don't worry, according to a report from AppleInsider, there are some practical tweaks coming to macOS 15 that are in the works. Notably, the System Settings app is set to receive the biggest changes, with other menus and app UIs also expecting some rearranging.

The last update to the Settings app happened with macOS Ventura, changing the name from System Preferences to System Settings and shifting to an iOS-style design, a change that ruffled the feathers of diehard Mac users. This time, the organizational system will reportedly be based on "priority and overall importance."

Read more
I ask again: Will Apple ever merge the Mac and iPad?
An Apple iPad and a MacBook together on a desk alongside a pair of headphones.

Every few months, we hear the same argument being made: Apple should bring the Mac and the iPad closer together -- or even merge them and their operating systems completely -- to create some sort of hybrid device that would solve all of Apple’s problems. While I don’t entirely agree with these assessments, they do provide an interesting look into how your Apple devices might work in the coming years.

Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman is the latest to throw his hat into the ring, and the reporter’s Power On newsletter has detailed what he believes Apple should do to shape the future of the Mac and the iPad.

Read more
4 high-end features Windows laptops still have over MacBooks
Lenovo Yoga 9i Gen 9 top down view showing tablet and pen.

Apple's MacBook lineup has exploded over the last several years, with its Silicon chipsets offering class-leading performance and efficiency. The MacBook Pro, in particular, is faster than many Windows laptops, longer-lasting than most, and has an excellent mini-LED display. There are many good reasons to choose a MacBook over a Windows laptop in today's market.

But all isn't lost for the Windows platform. Even aside from the upcoming Snapdragon X Elite laptops that look to be competitive, there are still some more basic features that you can only get on a Windows laptop at the moment. Here are the four that I keep coming back to.
Windows Hello

Read more