Skip to main content

What if Apple replaced the MacBook keyboard with a giant screen?

Lenovo Yoga Book
Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends
Julian Chokkattu/Digital Trends

Just yesterday, Apple patented the idea of a dual-screen MacBook. No keyboard. No trackpad. Just two screens that either fold together like a laptop or detach like a 2-in-1. While the patent doesn’t mean Apple is actually developing such a product, the idea of a future MacBook without a keyboard got us thinking about why this would or wouldn’t work.

What if Apple really did make a MacBook without a keyboard? What would it be like? Could it actually be done — and more importantly, is that what people would actually want?

People are very attached to physical keyboards — us included. When we need to get real work done, we depend on physical keyboards that we can type quickly on. There’s something about the tactile feedback of physical switches and buttons that makes that kind of speed possible. How many times have you been doing something on your smartphone and wished you were doing it on a laptop instead? The idea of taking that away on a machine that’s supposed to be a productivity computer seems counter-intuitive.

On the other hand, those were very similar arguments made about physical keyboards before the iPhone came out. Digital keyboards sucked, so people preferred physical ones. But once the engineers at Apple nailed the feeling of consistent accuracy on a touchscreen, we all said goodbye to physical keyboards and haven’t looked back since.

But would that work on a laptop? It’s not the first time such a device has been developed. We’ve seen concepts like Lenovo’s Yoga Book (pictured above), as well as all the rumors and patents surrounding Microsoft’s Andromeda project (or even Microsoft’s abandoned Courier project from the late 2000s).

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Two relevant examples of Apple engineering are worth mentioning: One makes me excited about the possibility of a dual-screen MacBook, and one makes me nervous about it.

The first is the MacBook’s current touchpad and keyboard inputs. In 2015, Apple introduced a redesigned touchpad on the MacBook called the “Force Touch Trackpad,” which didn’t actually click at all. Instead, it uses a set of electromagnets to simulate the feeling of tactile feedback. The feeling of “clicking” the trackpad is so smooth on MacBooks today that most people don’t even realize it’s fake.

Meanwhile, the new MacBook keyboards use “butterfly switches” to reproduce the feeling of key presses where there is almost no travel. Success in that department has been a bit less unanimous — especially for those who prefer a deeper key travel and analog switches. However, there’s no question that the keyboard works and can be used to type efficiently and quickly. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if Apple took it a step further on its next MacBook update and removed key travel entirely, replacing it with the same motorized simulation of the trackpad. It’d only be one more step to removing the physical keys and moving to an entirely digital surface.

All of that is proof that Apple can and will pay careful attention to replicating the feeling of physical stimulation on laptop inputs. The example that worries me is the Touch Bar.

The OLED touchscreen that replaced the function row on the most recent MacBook Pros was supposed to be a way of making laptops more like smartphones — more adaptable and context-sensitive. The idea was interesting conceptually, but not all that useful in practice. Again, it’s the reliability of tactile feedback that made the actual row of function keys useful. Having to use a touchscreen to quickly change brightness or audio volume is something I still haven’t gotten comfortable after all this time. Lacking any tactile feedback, I have to look down at my hands each time. It’s a total inconvenience.

With both of those examples intact, a dual-screen MacBook simultaneously makes me cringe and dream about the possibilities. What if the keyboard deck was more contextual? What if it could handle a mix of inputs — touch, type, and stylus? What if a keyboard was there when you needed it and disappeared when you didn’t? The potential is endless.

If Apple can do what it did with the trackpad on a larger scale, it just might be the future of computing. But if the Touch Bar is glimpse of the future, we’d rather stick with what we’ve got.

Editors' Recommendations

Luke Larsen
Luke Larsen is the Senior editor of computing, managing all content covering laptops, monitors, PC hardware, Macs, and more.
The first Copilot+ PC has been tested — and it destroys the MacBook
The Surface Laptop shown in front of a Copilot+ sign.

We've heard a lot about Microsoft's new Copilot+ PCs over the past few days, but we can finally put some hard data to the company's bold claims. Signal65, a benchmarking and analysis company, put the new Surface Laptop through its paces, and it absolutely wrecks the MacBook Air M3.

The laptop, equipped with a Snapdragon X Elite processor, put up impressive results across the board, but battery life stands out most. According to the report, the Surface Laptop lasted over 21 hours in a local video playback test. For reference, that's close to twice as long as the Surface Pro 9, and more than 15% longer than the MacBook Air M3.

Read more
How to choose between a MacBook and a Windows laptop
The keyboard and trackpad of the MacBook Pro.

When shopping for a new laptop one of the biggest decisions you'll make is choosing between MacBooks or Windows laptops. And it's not always an easy decision. New advances in chip technology are propelling even entry-level MacBooks to high-performance targets, and a shift in Windows laptops away from cheap plastics evens the playing field between these two platforms. Both Windows 11 and macOS are intuitive and clean operating systems. But where they differ comes down to one key element: their ecosystems.

What this means for you is that choosing an option from a list of the best laptops isn't so simple. The laptop you choose today can greatly influence which accessories you buy, which apps you use, and even what kind of phone you carry. Your entire workflow will depend on the platform you go with, from how you manage windows to which keyboard shortcuts work best. It's not a light decision.

Read more
How long do MacBooks last? Here’s when you’ll need to buy again
The M3 MacBook Air in front of a window.

There’s no doubt that Apple’s best MacBooks have a reputation for long-lasting quality, but what sort of longevity can you expect to get out of one? And just how long will Apple continue to support your laptop? Finally, what are the differences between the MacBook Air and the MacBook Pro?

These are no doubt important questions to consider when buying a new MacBook or even considering an upgrade. Here's everything you know about the longevity of your MacBook.
Lifespan of MacBook hardware

Read more