Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Gaming
  3. Reviews

Call of Juarez: Gunslinger review

By
call of juarez gunslinger review cover art
Call of Juarez: Gunslinger
Score Details
“Techland redeems the 'Call of Juarez' series with 'Gunslinger,' with a tall tale approach to the story that makes for unpredictable play.”
Pros
  • Smooth, impactful gunplay makes you feel like a Wild West gunslinger
  • Unreliable narrator creates some great story moments in which the world transforms around you as he backpedals
  • Lots of content for a downloadable game
Cons
  • Quickdraw minigame can be frustrating
  • Linear play dials back from the openness of the previous games

Call of Juarez: Gunslinger is like Tim Burton’s film Big Fish. An aging braggart recounts his fabulously interesting life – with some heavy embellishments – for a slack-jawed audience. It is a work of pure fantasy, a Wild West tall tale that recasts legends like Billy the Kid as supporting players in Silas Greaves’ one-man takedown of all outlaws everywhere.

It is also wildly entertaining.

Techland is in the position of having to redeem itself after the critically panned misstep that was 2011’s Call of Juarez: The Cartel. The earlier game’s present-day setting is gone in Gunslinger, and some newly added stylistic tweaks freshen up what would have otherwise been a straightforward first-person shooter.

The story is presented as a malleable flashback, with Silas Greaves recounting his exploits across the American frontier as he holds court at a local saloon. At any moment, the story might change as Greaves recalls something he forgot to mention or a heckler gives him hard time for one supposed “fact” or another.

20130506_COJG_screen_The_cold-blooded_bounty_hunter
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In gameplay terms, you might finding yourself fending off an Apache ambush in the middle of a hunt for fleeing outlaws, only for someone to ask why there are suddenly Native Americans in the mix. Greaves backpedals and explains, “No, they ambushed me like they were Apaches,” at which point the scene changes as your attackers transform into outlaws.

This happens frequently throughout Gunslinger. The environment reshapes itself right in front of you, and an enclosed space could suddenly have an exit that Greaves forgot to mention. At one point, your path leads to a fatal encounter with the business end of a speeding minecart, complete with a Game Over screen that quickly disappears as the game rewinds while Greaves explains how stupid it would have been to take that particular path.

The unusual story progression puts a nice twist on what would otherwise be a linear FPS, but Techland also deserves credit for its visually striking take on the Wild West. Gunslinger embraces a much more stylized look than past Call of Juarez games. Brightly colored textures that heavily emphasize shadows harken to the unique look of Gearbox Software’s Borderlands games, but the overall feel falls closer to that of a graphic novel grounded in some semblance of reality. It’s a treat to look at.

20130506_COJG_screen_Sawn-off_shotgun
Image used with permission by copyright holder

A satisfying combat loop quickly develops as you rack up kill combos and earn enough XP to level up in one of the three different skill trees that favors a long-range rifle, close-quarters shotguns, or building big combos with dual-wielded revolvers. The Gunslinger arsenal isn’t particularly large, but each firearm is finely tuned and a joy to play with. 

Outside of the surprisingly lengthy 6-8 hour campaign (for a download-only game), players also have the option of messing around in Duel or Arcade modes. Duel is essentially a boss rush mode that pits you against key baddies from the story in a quickdrawn gauntlet. The quickdraw minigame is a weak element in Gunslinger, with players expected to juggle a pair of meters by independently twiddling the left and right thumbsticks. It’s a functional solution to an aspect of Wild West lore that doesn’t easily translate into gameplay, but it could have been better.

Arcade mode offers much more in the way of replay value, breaking the story’s big combat moments up into a series of discrete encounters. You can easily max out a single skill tree in the course of one Gunslinger story playthrough, but you can’t go much further than that. Arcade acknowledges this with a “loadout” selection at the start of each challenge, giving you the option of trying out other styles of play.

Conclusion 

Techland redeems the Call of Juarez series and then some with Gunslinger. This is an undeniably fresh and original take on what most would probably call an ailing franchise, and it’s a game that is absolutely worth investing a handful of hours in if you’re a shooter fan. It may not reinvent the FPS, but Silas Greaves’ playable tall tale tweaks familiar formulas just enough to provide a memorable experience. No small feat for a download-only game that aims to compete in the medium’s most popular genre.

(This game was reviewed on the Xbox 360 using a code provided by the publisher)

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Adam Rosenberg
Adam Rosenberg
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Previously, Adam worked in the games press as a freelance writer and critic for a range of outlets, including Digital Trends…
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III trailer teases a No Russian reimagining
No Russian's reimagining in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III

Activision Blizzard has fully pulled back the curtain on Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III following an in-game event in its predecessor. This came alongside new gameplay that concludes by teasing a rebooted version of the series' infamous No Russian mission.
The gameplay trailer focuses on the campaign missions, which got a lot more detail in a post on the game's website. It affirms that the game follows Task Force 141 as they take on Vladimir Makarov and will feature some "Open Combat Missions" that give players multiple ways to complete objectives. The gameplay seems to mainly feature a stealthy run to one of these levels. Of course, the trailer's most shocking moment comes at the end.
Gameplay Reveal Trailer | Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III
We see Makarov text someone "No Russian," before they pull out a gun on a crowded plane. If you don't remember, No Russian was one of the original Modern Warfare II's most infamous missions, as it had players partake in a mass shooting terrorist attack at an airport with Russians. The level has influenced the tone of this rebooted Modern Warfare series, and it now looks like Modern Warfare III is set to reimagine this mission in some way, following up the Modern Warfare II post-credit scene that referenced it.

While the trailer focused on the campaign mainly, that post confirmed a lot of new info on multiplayer and Modern Warfare Zombies too. Its multiplayer features all 16 launch maps from 2009's Modern Warfare II, two larger Battle maps for Ground War and Invasion, and an even bigger War map for the return of the War Mode introduced in Call of Duty: WWII. Map voting returns, so you can have a say in where you want to play a match.  Finally, Activision says Modern Warfare Zombies takes place in a new open world where players will fight Dark Aether Zombies, complete missions, and incorporate Extraction game elements. 
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III launches on PC, PlayStation 4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S on November 10.

Read more
Activision teases Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III’s biggest improvements
The official logo for Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III.

Activision has just teased lots of new details about Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III, which launches this November. That includes the fact that the game will contain a Zombies mode, more open-ended campaign missions, and introduce a new "Call of Duty HQ" that will serve as a hub for all future Call of Duty games.

These details were all revealed in a new blog post posted on the series' website ahead of the in-game event that will give us our first in-depth look at Modern Warfare II. In it, Activision clears up a lot of rumors about the game to try and show that Modern Warfare III is still an "incredible, premium annual game experience across Campaign, Multiplayer and Co-operative modes" despite reportedly starting development as a Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II expansion.
Some of the features listed we already knew about, like the fact that this year's campaign features Makarov as a villain and that players can carry over their progression and inventory from Modern Warfare II. Others are new, though, like the fact that the campaign will feature new "Open Combat" missions. That seems to imply that Modern Warfare III's campaign levels will offer more freedom than is typical in a Call of Duty level. When it comes to multiplayer, the post states that players can expect new combat vest, perk, tac-stance movement, and after-market parts systems in addition to some Riochet Anti-Cheat Improvements.
More importantly, it's finally officially confirmed that this year's game will feature a Zombies mode. Titled Modern Warfare Zombies, Activision calls it the "largest Zombies offering to date." Finally, Activision made it clear that it plans on keeping all Call of Duty content closely bundled together going forward. After Modern Warfare III launches, Call of Duty HQ will be introduced and serve as "one access point for your future Call of Duty content."
While there aren't many specifics on all of these things, we at least now have a broader picture of what to expect from Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III when it launches on November 10.

Read more
Does Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 have Hardcore mode?
Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 guy with a gun

In Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, players have access to a wide variety of multiplayer game modes including Team Deathmatch, Search and Destroy, and the new Prisoner Capture. One of the most popular modes in the series is Hardcore, which has been in the series for years. This intense mode removes the HUD and increases damage across the board. But does this mode appear in the new Modern Warfare 2?

Here's what you need to know about the Hardcore mode in Modern Warfare 2.
Does Modern Warfare 2 have a Hardcore mode?
When Modern Warfare 2 first launched, it didn't have a Hardcode mode, much to the disappointment of fans. Instead, the game had a mode called Tier 1, which was basically a rudimentary version of Hardcore mode, with some missing features. For instance, there's no HUD, whatsoever, no hitmarkers, and no killfeed, which made the mode hard to actually play in some cases. Thankfully, Activision finally did add Hardcore more at the start of 2023, replacing the Tier 1 mode from before.
What is Hardcore mode?

Read more