Skip to main content

Amazon might preach open pastures, but it’s not above a little herding

Amazon Fire TV
Image used with permission by copyright holder

In the great software wars, we back our favorite operating systems with a zeal normally reserved for sports teams and political parties. Loyalty to a given ecosystem has become more than just a matter of different features and app selection, it’s a commitment. And as anyone who’s attempted to switch between them can tell you, the difficulty of severing ties is about fun as getting a new driver’s license or canceling a gym membership. To paraphrase the worst of The Godfather movies, they keeping pulling you back in.

But as all eyes have been focused on Microsoft, Apple and Google’s very public fight for our hearts and finger tips, Amazon hooked us while our backs were turned. And its latest play, the Fire TV shows just how deep the hook is set. 

The first taste, as they say, is always free. For Amazon, that meant bundling Instant Video in for free with its already seemingly too-good-to-be-true Prime offering. Taken on its own, the service’s selection wasn’t much to speak of: 5,000 streaming titles, the majority of which seemed to overlap with every other streaming service out there. Not nearly enough to convince the majority of us to dump our Netflix or Hulu accounts, but hey, Instant Video was just icing on the free shipping cake — even last month when the company upped the price by a $20 a year. Free shipping and the ability to stream Spring Breakers whenever I want? Not gonna look that gift horse in the mouth. 

The truth is that the Fire TV exists to sell you Amazon content, first and foremost.

Ever since the 2011 launch of Instant Video, the arrival of an Amazon set top box has been something of a foregone conclusion. It’s yet another piece in the puzzle for Amazon’s content strategy, which we’ve already seen played out in the form of the company’s Kindle e-readers and Fire tablets: offer users a low-cost, simple-to-use piece of hardware to access Amazon content, and they’ll keep coming back, and keep buying. It’s the classic “give away the razor, sell the blade” business model: Lose money upfront and you’ll make it all up on the backend. 

It works. Amazon devotees who have already picked up a Kindle Fire will find the experience on the newly announced Fire TV comfortingly familiar, with the set-top box running Amazon’s extremely user-friendly Mojito Fire OS skin atop an Android base. And like the company’s tablet, running on Android makes porting apps from Google’s popular operating system a relatively easy undertaking, but it doesn’t mean going so far as actually offering directly access to Google Play. 

For all the promises of “open ecosystems” we heard from Amazon around the product’s launch, the truth is that the box exists to sell you Amazon content, first and foremost. While it’s true that you’ll be able to watch your Netflix and Hulu subscriptions on the device, when time comes to actually buy those videos, well, Amazon wants to be the service for you. You’re committed to a Prime membership for the long haul, remember? After all, that’s where Amazon’s really making the money here. 

AmazonFireTV VoiceSearch
Image used with permission by copyright holder

As for actually convincing users to pick up a Fire TV, well, that’s a bit of a tougher proposition. A year ago, before Google and Roku hit the scene with their ultra low-cost offerings, the fight would have been much easier for a $100 Amazon set top box, and it really could claim to be “open” compared to Apple TV. Now, Fire TV has stiffer competition. But Amazon has what none of its competitors have: one of the greatest billboards in the world, in the form of Amazon.com. 

It’s a platform that reaches early adopters and casual users alike, and one that has served the company incredibly well in the past, selling e-readers to book buyers and tablets. Head over there now, and you’ll see another friendly letter signed by CEO Jeff Bezos, monopolizing 75-percent of that incredibly valuable real estate. In it, the exec promises, “the easiest way to enjoy Netflix, Prime Instant Video, Hulu Plus, WatchESPN, low-cost video rentals and more.”  $99 for instant access to more than 200,000 TV episodes and movies? Sounds too good to be true. Head on over to the Instant Video page, and you’ll see the same. 

Using its store to sell its own products has been successful for Amazon in the past, and will likely deliver for the company once again, especially when the holidays roll around. After all, users looking to give the set-top box as a gift don’t have to worry about ecosystem loyalty in the way they would with an Android or iOS device. 

Whether we like it or not, Amazon knows how to make us an offer we can’t refuse.

Check out our review of the Amazon Fire TV media streamer.

Editors' Recommendations

Brian Heater
Brian Heater has worked at number of tech pubs, including Engadget, PCMag and Laptop. His writing has appeared in Spin…
Amazon is giving you 6 months of MGM+ when you buy a new Fire TV
Amazon announcing a partnership with MGM.

Amazon is giving six months of free access to MGM+ in conjunction with the purchase of a new Fire TV. The announcement came as part of Amazon's massive annual device event at HQ2 in Arlington, Virginia. And that means low-cost sticks, as well as more expensive televisions running Amazon Fire TV.

Unsurprisingly, Amazon also used the event to announce a new Fire TV Stick 4K, Fire TV Stick 4K Max, and Fire TV Soundbar. Amazon announced in March 2023 that more than 200 million Fire TV devices had been sold worldwide, and that number is poised to continue growing strongly.

Read more
TCL’s latest Q and S Class televisions price Fire TV to sell
The TCL Q6 television as seen in a press lifestyle picture.

The TCL Q6 as seen in a promotional photo. TCL / TCL

The cool thing about modern TVs is that they come in all sorts of sizes and flavors. To that end, TCL has released pricing on its Amazon Fire TV-powered Q and S Class televisions (as we continue to wait on the QD-Mini LED fare).

Read more
Roku and Amazon are so close to making subtitles easy to toggle
The Roku Voice Remote Pro, and the Amazon Alexa Voice Remote Pro.

The idea that remote controls should include a dedicated button for captions is not, in and of itself, a bad one. In fact, it makes a whole lot of sense, whether the remote belongs to a television or a peripheral like Roku or Amazon Fire TV. We acknowledge the fact that it would add complexity and, possibly, cost to a device. (And that it's relatively easy to just flip 'em on and off inside apps as it is.) But we believe it would be worth it.

We didn’t pick Roku and Amazon Fire TV out of thin air in that previous paragraph. They are the two biggest streaming platforms in the world. And as it turns out, they both have remote controls with user-programmable buttons. While that’s not quite the same thing as what we're imploring the likes of Roku, Amazon, Google, Apple, and others to employ, it’s something that’s available now. (Though the remotes in question aren’t shipped by default with every device — you’ll have to spend more to get them.)

Read more