Skip to main content

Judge Dismisses Some Damage Claims Against YouTube for Int’l Video

Judge Dismisses Some Damage Claims Against YouTube for Int

U.S. District Judge Louis Stanton has dismissed some damage claims in a class action copyright infringement lawsuit against YouTube and Google led by The Football Association Premier League, ruling the copyright holders of foreign works can’t sue Google for punitive damages arising from those materials’ distribution on YouTube—unless those works are registered for copyright in the United States. However, the judge did rule that if the the copyright holder prevail in their infringement suit, they could seek punitive damages for live broadcasts distributed via YouTube, under a “live broadcast exemption” in U.S. copyright law.

The plaintiffs, representing a group of international sports and music copyright holders, had argued foreign works were exempt from the U.S. Copyright Act’s registration requirement. The judge’s ruling does not exempt the plaintiffs from seeking statutory damages, if they should prevail at trial. However, save in the case of live broadcasts, they may not seek punitive damages. The upshot to Google, if it is found guilty of infringement, could be huge: the plaintiff’s recovery could reach into the billions of dollars if they win their case; punitive damages could easily double or triple that amount.

Google has consistently maintained the infringement claims are without merit.

Judge Stanton’s ruling reenforces an earlier ruling he made in Viacom’s $1 billion copyright infringement suit against Google and YouTube. Both suits were filed in 2007, and have have their discovery phases consolidated. In March, Stanton ruled Viacom couldn’t seek common law punitive damages against Google, because they aren’t available under the Copyright Act.

The Football Association Premier League’s suit seeks $1.65 billion in damages.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Eve MotionBlinds Upgrade Kit and Blinds Collection join the Matter lineup
The Eve MotionBlinds Upgrade Kit being installed.

Eve is a prominent name in the smart home world, with the company responsible for a variety of devices covering everything from smart plugs and security cameras to smart light switches and motion sensors. Its catalog is growing even more enticing today, with the Eve Blinds Collection and MotionBlinds Upgrade Kit gaining Matter support.

The MotionBlinds Upgrade Kit will likely appeal to more customers, as it costs just $200 and works with most existing setups. Installation is as simple as removing your shades, placing the MotionBlinds Upgrade Kit through the roller rod, then reinstalling the unit on your windows. Blinds with a roller between 1.5 inches and 2.0 inches are compatible with the upgrade kit.

Read more
Philips Hue lights have a rare discount, but there’s a catch
A TV with ambient backlighting from Philips Hue.

One of the cool things about Philips Hue lighting is how much freedom it gives you over creating the perfect ambiance in your home. One of the cool things about buying Philips Hue products over at Best Buy right now is how much freedom Best Buy is giving you over what you buy to save money. Right now, when you buy two or more select Philips Hue smart lighting product in Best Buy's offer builder, you can save 15%. Tap the button below to start building your own bundle and see all of the products available. While they don't include the best smart light bulbs that Philips produces, you'll be amazed by the versatility of the lightstrips. Or keep reading for an overview of some of the top picks from the bundle.

What you should purchase from the Philips Hue offer builder
The place to start with this deal is the and the if you don't already have them. These are the devices that take your movies, music, and games and syncs them to your lights.

Read more
Samsung’s futuristic Jet Bot AI+ robot vacuum is $400 off
The Samsung Jet Bot AI+ Robot Vacuum cleaning the floor.

For families who need a lot of help in keeping their floors spotless, the Samsung Jet Bot AI+ is an investment that you'll want to make. It's pretty expensive at its original price of $1,300, but a $400 discount from Samsung pulls it down to $900. It's still not cheap, but this futuristic robot vacuum could be the only device that you need to keep dirt, debris, and pet hair away from your sight. You're going to have to complete your purchase for it as soon as possible though, as there's no telling when the offer expires.

Why you should buy the Samsung Jet Bot AI+ robot vacuum
The Samsung Jet Bot AI+ checks all the boxes in the features that are recommended by our guide on how to choose a robot vacuum. It's equipped with powerful sensors and object recognition technology that allows it to avoid furniture when it's cleaning your floors, while LiDAR technology allows it to create accurate maps of the rooms in your home so that it can properly navigate and clean more efficiently. The robot vacuum also features a five-layer filtration system that allows it to release clean air, and when it's done, it goes back to its Clean Station where it empties its contents.

Read more