Australian Galaxy Tab ban extended another week

By Geoff Duncan December 2, 2011

samsung-galaxy-tab-101-vs-ipad-2 — Image used with permission by copyright holder

It seemed like Samsung had finally carved out a legal victory against Apple in its long-running effort to sell the Galaxy Tab Android tablet in Australia—but the feeling may have been short lived. Although the full Federal Court of Australia overturned an earlier injunction on the sales of Galaxy Tabs in Australia this week—clearing the way for the devices to go on sale today—the court has now pushed that date back to December 9 to give Apple time to file its objections to the case.

Samsung’s Galaxy Tab tablet was scheduled to go on sale in Australia September 12, but in August Samsung actually volunteered to defer the start of sales until September 30th while the dispute with Apple worked its way through the court. A judge then ruled the Samsung Galaxy Tab infringed on elements of Apple’s iPad 2 and delayed sales; Samsung argued that Apple’s claims were based on a comparison to a U.S. model of the Galaxy Tab, and offered Apple prototypes of an Australian version of the tablet. Apple then temporarily excluded two of its five patent claims against the Galaxy Tab in Australia, but the sales ban was still in effect.

In the most recent ruling, the full Federal Court ruled that the judge who issued the initial injunction did not sufficiently assess the strength of Apple’s patent infringement claims when issuing the initial injunction. Apple immediately requested a stay of orders, and the matter has now been expedited to a special leave list to be considered by the court next Friday.

No date has been set for a full hearing on Apple’s claims that the Samsung Galaxy Tab copies the iPad. The court seems cognizant that the life cycle of these products is short, noting that further delays in the sale of the Galaxy Tab would more-or-less “kill off” the device.

Apple has been going all-out against Samsung with its claims the Galaxy Tab copies the design and technology of the iPad: cases are pending in the United States, Japan, and South Korea, and Apple has won another injunction on the sale of Galaxy Tab devices in Germany.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Computing

Best Apple deals: Save on AirPods, Apple Watch, iPad, MacBook

Apple MacBook Air M1 open, on a table.

Apple is one of the biggest companies in the world, and if you're looking for some great tech, then you probably already know that Apple makes some of the best wireless earbuds, the best smartwatches, the best laptops, and even the best tablets. That said, it does also garner a very premium price tag, which is a pretty big part of the brand itself, meaning that for a lot of folks in the Apple ecosystem, making any sort of upgrade or expansion to that ecosystem can be very costly. On the bright side, there are a ton of great Apple deals out there in the world, whether it's trade-in value from Apple, or direct discounts from Amazon and Best Buy, you have options.

That's why we've gone out and searched through various big retailers to find you some of the best deals we can find. That includes everything from the MacBook deals, AirPods deals, Apple TV deals and Apple Watch deals to the AirTag, so hopefully, you can find the perfect deal that fits your needs and budget.
Apple AirTag (4-Pack) -- $79, was $99

Mobile

The one thing stopping me from buying a new iPad

Three 2021 iPads are stacked on a table.

Want an iPad? Apple wants you to be paying attention to the new iPad Pro -- and for good reason. It's the thinnest product Apple has ever created, which is impressive considering it packs in a laptop-level M4 processor, a gorgeous display, and a number of new software tricks. But the announcement concealed something far more important: the dustbinning of the 9th-gen iPad. The last of the "retro" iPad designs, the 9th-gen is now finally retired from the stage, and for me, it means this is my last chance to grab a quick and reasonable upgrade for my 7th-gen iPad.

I figured I could grab the 9th-gen for a decent discount now that it's on the way out -- and to Apple's credit, I absolutely could. But a realization began to sink in as I shopped, and I came away without making that final purchase.

Mobile

Save up to $1,150 on the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra today

Recent apps view on the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra.

Tablets are great if you're the sort of person who doesn't want to lug around a laptop all the time and finds having a tablet an excellent alternative. If that's the case and you want to use a tablet as a laptop replacement, then you'll want to go for one of the best tablets on the market, such as the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra. Luckily, there's a pretty substantial Memorial Day offer from Samsung that gives you a straight discount from $950 to $1,200, as well as up to $800 worth of trade-in credit. That means you could potentially get the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra for as low as $150, assuming you trade in a high-end tablet, although you're more likely to get half of that if yours is a couple of years old. Still, the original $250 discount plus another $400-$800 can be pretty substantial.

Why you should buy the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra
When we originally reviewed the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9, our conclusion was that it was a hard tablet to recommend, primarily because it was outrageously expensive, especially since the iPad Pro is cheaper. That said, with the discount and potential trade-in credit, the price isn't so bad, and some of the other excellent features start to stand out, such as the truly massive 14.6-inch screen, which is bigger than the 12.9-inch iPad Pro. Of course, that does come with its own problem, which is that it's pretty heavy to hold, especially for long periods, although if you use it with a case that has a stand, that issue can be substantially mitigated.