Skip to main content

Dear B&N: We’ll miss your originality now that the Nook is just another Tab

Brian Heater 060914
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Read our full Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 Nook review.

Hey Barnes & Noble. It’s been a while, I know. You haven’t released a new device in a while, and I rarely pop my head into your Union Square location ever since I stopped working in the neighborhood. I wanted to tell you that I caught wind of the news that you and Samsung are seeing each other now, and I’d like to congratulate you. It’s been a tough year, I know, what with last quarter’s 58.2-percent drop in sales on Nook tablets and accessories, but you’ve certainly found a strong partner in Samsung.

Your better half from Korea has a solid second place position in the smartphone and tablet markets, with numbers that only seem to be increasing. Hell, if anyone’s going to give you a fighting chance against the behemoth that Amazon and its ever-growing hardware wing (at least anyone who’s not Apple), it’s Samsung. And the company has certainly proven its dedication to throwing products against the wall to see what sticks.

All I see is a Samsung tablet with some Barnes & Noble software tossed in for good measure.

That said, the news has me a little concerned that this partnership has the potential to make you lose sight of what made you such a unique and intriguing hardware maker in the first place.

Now, I realize that you’ve stated your intentions to remain your own company in the hardware game, a sentiment that, believe me, wasn’t lost on me. And while I know my letter won’t have much effect now that the ink has dried on all of the contracts, hopefully this can be a ways toward reminding you what set you apart.

Sure, Amazon has any number of competitive advances when it comes to hardware, not the least of which is having, arguably, the greatest product billboard on the Internet, in the form of its homepage. Meanwhile, you struggled with the growing pains of transforming from a massive bookstore chain into a digital company, a move that has killed so many weaker companies, from Borders, on down. But even still, year after year and model after model, you stuck in there, with bold and interesting hardware decisions that helped push the e-reader — and later low-end tablet — market.

In 2008, you introduced the first Nook, a fascinating little e-reader that incorporated a second, color input and ran Android, a feature that allowed some clever users to port apps like Pandora onto the thing. A year later, you took your first swipe at the tablet space, with a low-cost Froyo device featuring a unique industrial design by hotshot designer Yves Behar. If you ask me though, you really hit your stride later than year, with the introduction of the Nook Simple Touch, a plucky little device built specifically with the human hand in mind — perfect for those marathon reading sessions as I worked my way through The Power Broker.

Nook Simple Touch
Image used with permission by copyright holder

You beat Amazon to the touchscreen punch with that one, and got out to an even earlier lead with the Nook Simple Touch With Glowlight, which opened up E-ink devices to the world of reading in the dark (and if your ad copy was to be believed, managed to save a few marriages in the process). All the while, you held onto terrific features that Amazon had no time for as its devices began moving more uniformly into a desert of industrial design, adopting the same touchscreen-dominated rectangular black design as everyone else in the hardware space.

You held onto your SD card slot and your physical page turn buttons — hell, you even kept that lovely bezel around in a celebration of form and function and, most importantly, an acknowledgment that your thumb needs a place to go while you’re reading a book. You helped bring high-res displays to a low price point, maintained an elongated form factor for magazine and newspaper readers, and eventually you defiantly sent a shot across the Kindle Fire’s bow by opening your tablets up to the full Google Play Store, making for arguably the best low-cost tablets with that functionality, while Amazon relied on its own content strategy to subsidize the cost of its own products.

Amazon’s virtual monopoly of the e-reader space could do with some innovative competition.

But now, as I sit here on my couch, looking at pictures of the Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 Nook, all I see is a Samsung tablet with some Barnes & Noble software tossed in for good measure. On the front of the device, there’s no indication of your involvement. Heck, even the name makes the whole thing feel like something of an afterthought. Why? By last count, there are currently 857 different Galaxy Tabs on the market (a rough estimate, granted). What difference will number 858 really make — particularly as Amazon continues to pump R&D into its Fire line, releasing new and innovative features with each iteration, while maintaining budget prices.

Listen, I realize that such things cost money, and by the looks of it, there isn’t much to spare around the Barnes & Noble design labs these days. I understand why signing a deal with Samsung was in your best interest. You get to remain in the tablet market — if admittedly, only peripherally — while Samsung does all of the heavy lifting. Or, perhaps more accurately, all of the heavy product rebranding. But let’s be honest for a minute: The most exciting things that were happening in the world of Nook were, most often, happening on the hardware side of things.

So please keep your word and continue to maintain an interested in the devoted e-reader market. Amazon is making some fine readers, to be sure, but here in the States especially, the company’s virtual monopoly of the space could do with some innovative competition. And maybe before you sign the paper work on the next edition of the Samsung Nook, maybe toss some of those interesting design ideas Samsung’s way. Then maybe this could be a fruitful partnership after all.

Topics
Brian Heater
Brian Heater has worked at number of tech pubs, including Engadget, PCMag and Laptop. His writing has appeared in Spin…
AT&T just made it a lot easier to upgrade your phone
AT&T Storefront with logo.

Do you want to upgrade your phone more than once a year? What about three times a year? Are you on AT&T? If you answered yes to those questions, then AT&T’s new “Next Up Anytime” early upgrade program is made for you. With this add-on, you’ll be able to upgrade your phone three times a year for just $10 extra every month. It will be available starting July 16.

Currently, AT&T has its “Next Up” add-on, which has been available for the past several years. This program costs $6 extra per month and lets you upgrade by trading in your existing phone after at least half of it is paid off. But the new Next Up Anytime option gives you some more flexibility.

Read more
Motorola is selling unlocked smartphones for just $150 today
Someone holding the Moto G Stylus 5G (2024).

Have you been looking for phone deals but don’t want to spend a ton of money on flagship devices from Apple and Samsung? Have you ever considered investing in an unlocked Motorola? For a limited time, the company is offering a $100 markdown on the Motorola Moto G 5G. It can be yours for just $150, and your days and nights of phone-shopping will finally be over!

Why you should buy the Motorola Moto G 5G
Powered by the Snapdragon 480+ 5G CPU and 4GB of RAM, the Moto G delivers exceptional performance across the board. From UI navigation to apps, games, and camera functions, you can expect fast load times, next to no buffering, and smooth animations. You’ll also get up to 128GB of internal storage that you’ll be able to use for photos, videos, music, and any other mobile content you can store locally. 

Read more
The Nokia 3210 is the worst phone I’ve used in 2024
A person holding the Nokia 3210, showing the screen.

Where do I even start with the Nokia 3210? Not the original, which was one of the coolest phones to own back in a time when Star Wars: Episode 1 -- The Phantom Menace wasn’t even a thing, but the latest 2024 reissue that has come along to save us all from digital overload, the horror of social media, and the endless distraction that is the modern smartphone.

Except behind this facade of marketing-friendly do-goodery hides a weapon of torture, a device so foul that I’d rather sit through multiple showings of Jar Jar Binks and the gang hopelessly trying to bring back the magic of A New Hope than use it.
The Nokia 3210 really is that bad

Read more