Skip to main content

Google, Apple, and Amazon under fire over freemium app sales model

best android tablet apps version 1432138873
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Italy’s Antitrust and Competition Authority launched an investigation that looks at the popular freemium app sales model currently in use in Google’s Play Store, Apple’s App Store, and Amazon’s Appstore.

The Wall Street Journal reports that the committee launched the investigation under the justification that customers could be misled by the “free” label. According to the regulator, anyone who downloads those apps believing that they are free, only for them to be unknowingly charged for items within the app. While all three app stores, as well as Gameloft, are on the hook, Google could face fines up to €5 million (~$6.9 million) if found to have mislead users.

The freemium app sales model, a common model found in use across all three app stores, involves offering your app for free. Within the app, users are then allowed to purchase features or items, such as in-game currency and items for your in-game character. Google has had trouble in the past with freemium apps, with a mother suing the company back in March, accusing the company for having the Play Store as a place where games and apps lure children into spending money.

This is not the first time the Italian antitrust committee fined a company for business practices considered damaging to consumers. Back in 2011, the committee fined Apple €900,000 ($1.2 million) for misleading customers into purchasing AppleCare, the company’s extended warranty plans, for products that were already covered. Apple also received another smaller fine before the company finally changed the way it marketed AppleCare.

Android Authority’s Jonathan Feist found that 147 out of the top 150 grossing apps in the Play Store are freemium apps. It’s unknown whether the investigation will solely focus on the freemium app sales model or whether the committee will also look into paid apps that offer in-app purchases. According to the committee, the investigation will likely be concluded before the end of the year.

Editors' Recommendations

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
Google is making it easier for you to find and download Android apps
Google Play on the Oppo Find N2.

Google announced a wide range of features for Android phones at the I/O 2024 developers conference earlier today. However, the event was not all about user-facing changes. The company also revealed a handful of new tricks for developers to showcase their apps effectively while maintaining a vigilant eye on safety.

Among the most important changes -- one that is also going to make life easier for users - is support for more payment options. The most notable of these is support for installment subscriptions, which has already yielded positive results for developers in the early access phase.

Read more
Google Messages vs. Samsung Messages: Which app should you use?
Google messages versus samsung messages app icons side by side on Galaxy Z Fold 5.

Amid the rise of third-party messaging apps, texting remains a popular means of messaging in the U.S. If you own an Android phone, you've likely used or heard of Google Messages, which is positioned as the default text messaging app for Android. It is the culmination of Google's long history with multiple messaging platforms. Google has pursued smartphone companies to use its Dialer and Messages apps as their default since at least 2017 and now mandates them to use Google Messages as the default messaging app on all devices.

Meanwhile, if you have been a Samsung user in the past, you have likely also known and experienced the Samsung Messages app, which comes preinstalled on all Samsung phones and cannot be uninstalled. This is despite losing its spot as the default messaging app on Samsung Galaxy smartphones.

Read more
How to install the Google Play Store on an Amazon Fire tablet
The back of the Amazon Fire Max 11 tablet.

The Amazon Fire lineup is filled with affordable Android tablets. Offering plenty of functionality without the price tag associated with products from Samsung or Lenovo, Amazon's home-grown family of tablets is an easy recommendation for frugal shoppers. There's a bit of caveat to the lineup, however, as none of them come preinstalled with the Google Play Store.

Read more