Skip to main content

What can snoops learn from your metadata? Way more than you thought

NSA metadata collection
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Since Americans learned in June of last year that the National Security Agency collects the telephone “metadata” of virtually every phone call within the United States, little has changed in what will soon be a year. One federal judge found that the Patriot Act-backed program almost certainly violates our Fourth Amendment rights, while another found (PDF) the practice legally sound. President Obama has offered minor efforts to reform metadata collection, while repeatedly reassuring Americans that “nobody is listening to the content of people’s phone calls.”

Meanwhile, an analysis by the nonprofit New America Foundation found that “bulk collection of American phone metadata has had no discernible impact on preventing acts of terrorism and only the most marginal of impacts on preventing terrorist-related activity.” And yet, the collection continues unabated.

“Bulk collection of American phone metadata has had no discernible impact on preventing acts of terrorism.”

In short, the telephone metadata situation remains a confusing mess. What is becoming increasingly less vague is this: Metadata can reveal a staggering amount of personal details about our lives, a fact further proved this week in a newly released study by Stanford University researchers. Their results are nothing short of disturbing, showing once again that it’s time for the law to prevent the collection of innocent people’s metadata just as it protects us from any other unreasonable seizure of private information.

The researchers rounded up a pool willing to install a specially-developed app called MetaPhone, which would give them an NSA-like view of calling habits. Using metadata – numbers called, time and duration of calls, unique serial number of devices used in calls, and sometimes the location of placed calls , the researchers were able to uncover a wealth of highly personal information about the callers.

“The degree of sensitivity among contacts took us aback,” write Jonathan Mayer and Patrick Mutchler, the researchers who conducted the study. “Participants had calls with Alcoholics Anonymous, gun stores, NARAL Pro-Choice, labor unions, divorce lawyers, sexually transmitted disease clinics, a Canadian import pharmacy, strip clubs, and much more. This was not a hypothetical parade of horribles. These were simple inferences, about real phone users, that could trivially be made on a large scale.”

In conclusion, write the researchers, “reasonable minds can disagree about the policy and legal constraints that should be imposed on [NSA] databases. The science, however, is clear: Phone metadata is highly sensitive.”

NSA floor seal
Image used with permission by copyright holder

For those of you who’ve been paying attention to this issue for the past nine months, this is anything but surprising. Back in August, the American Civil Liberties Union challenged (PDF) the Obama administration’s assertion that metadata is not protected by the Fourth Amendment with comments from Ed Felten, a professor of computer science at Princeton University. As Felten wrote in his legal brief, “Telephony metadata can be extremely revealing, both at the level of individual calls and, especially, in the aggregate.”

To further his point, Felten provided the following example: “A young woman calls her gynecologist; then immediately calls her mother; then a man who, during the past few months, she had repeatedly spoken to on the telephone after 11 p.m.; followed by a call to a family planning center that also offers abortions. A likely storyline emerges that would not be as evident by examining the record of a single telephone call.”

“The science … is clear: Phone metadata is highly sensitive.”

While the ACLU lost its case against the Obama administration, the group continues to push its campaign for greater protection of all types of metadata – and we would all be wise to support it. That means writing and calling your representatives in Congress, writing and calling the White House, signing petitions, and otherwise voicing your opposition to what has become a truly 21st century privacy problem.

It may be true that you believe you have nothing to hide. Perhaps you’re OK with the government knowing vast details about your personal affairs. But many of us, myself included, do not. We know that data is forever, and the people with access to that data may not always be trustworthy – if, indeed, they are trustworthy now. We know that the technology to exploit that data is only getting more powerful by the day. And we believe that there are ways to protect all our safety without demolishing the freedom to live a private life. Do us all a favor, and don’t let this issue slide further back into our collective mind.

(Image credit Sidarta via Shutterstock.com)

Andrew Couts
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Features Editor for Digital Trends, Andrew Couts covers a wide swath of consumer technology topics, with particular focus on…
AT&T just made it a lot easier to upgrade your phone
AT&T Storefront with logo.

Do you want to upgrade your phone more than once a year? What about three times a year? Are you on AT&T? If you answered yes to those questions, then AT&T’s new “Next Up Anytime” early upgrade program is made for you. With this add-on, you’ll be able to upgrade your phone three times a year for just $10 extra every month. It will be available starting July 16.

Currently, AT&T has its “Next Up” add-on, which has been available for the past several years. This program costs $6 extra per month and lets you upgrade by trading in your existing phone after at least half of it is paid off. But the new Next Up Anytime option gives you some more flexibility.

Read more
Motorola is selling unlocked smartphones for just $150 today
Someone holding the Moto G Stylus 5G (2024).

Have you been looking for phone deals but don’t want to spend a ton of money on flagship devices from Apple and Samsung? Have you ever considered investing in an unlocked Motorola? For a limited time, the company is offering a $100 markdown on the Motorola Moto G 5G. It can be yours for just $150, and your days and nights of phone-shopping will finally be over!

Why you should buy the Motorola Moto G 5G
Powered by the Snapdragon 480+ 5G CPU and 4GB of RAM, the Moto G delivers exceptional performance across the board. From UI navigation to apps, games, and camera functions, you can expect fast load times, next to no buffering, and smooth animations. You’ll also get up to 128GB of internal storage that you’ll be able to use for photos, videos, music, and any other mobile content you can store locally. 

Read more
The Nokia 3210 is the worst phone I’ve used in 2024
A person holding the Nokia 3210, showing the screen.

Where do I even start with the Nokia 3210? Not the original, which was one of the coolest phones to own back in a time when Star Wars: Episode 1 -- The Phantom Menace wasn’t even a thing, but the latest 2024 reissue that has come along to save us all from digital overload, the horror of social media, and the endless distraction that is the modern smartphone.

Except behind this facade of marketing-friendly do-goodery hides a weapon of torture, a device so foul that I’d rather sit through multiple showings of Jar Jar Binks and the gang hopelessly trying to bring back the magic of A New Hope than use it.
The Nokia 3210 really is that bad

Read more