Skip to main content

Photo of Jesse James bought on eBay for $10 turns out to be worth millions

Image used with permission by copyright holder

A photo of the infamous outlaw Jesse James that was bought by an eBay shopper for $10 could be worth as much as $2 million.

Brit Justin Whiting has been collecting old photos via eBay for several years, and when he bought this one showing a man in a suit, he had no idea it was of Jesse James.

The eBay listing said simply: “Victorian tintype photo young man in dark suit standing by chair.” Such “tintype” images were made by applying chemicals to a thin metal sheet and were popular in the mid-19th century.

Whiting added the 3.5-inch by 2.5-inch photo to his collection last year and forgot about it until recently, when he decided to go through his photos to see if any of them had any special significance.

A long-standing interest in the Wild West prompted him to take a closer look at this particular image, which he later learned was taken in the early 1860s when Jesse James was a teen.

Whiting, 45, felt pretty sure the photo was of James, but couldn’t be 100-percent certain, so he sent a digital copy of it to William Dunniway, a California-based expert on 19th-century photography.

After studying another well-known image of James — apparently taken during the very same photo session but showing only James’ head and shoulders — Dunniway was convinced that Whiting’s picture showed the outlaw and that the image itself was genuine. The fact that this one shows the notorious bandit head-to-toe makes it particularly special.

The next step was to take it to a forensic expert to confirm that the image did indeed show Jesse James.

Whiting told the BBC he had “a bit of a nervous wait” while forensic specialist Kent Gibson examined the photo.

But Gibson didn’t need to long reach his conclusion. “I could tell immediately,” he said after running the picture through several facial recognition programs. “It scored off the charts.”

Whiting is currently putting the word out about the photo to see what kind of interest it generates among collectors and other interested parties. He said he’s aware that billionaire businessman William Koch purchased a photo of another legendary outlaw, Billy the Kid, for $2.3 million at auction in 2011, and wonders if his Jesse James photo might generate a similar amount if it goes under the hammer.

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
The best photo printers you can buy in 2024
Alan compares draft, standard, and high-quality photos from Epson's EcoTank ET-8500.

A comparison of draft, standard, and high-quality photos from Epson's EcoTank ET-8500. Tracey Truly / Digital Trends

If you love sharing photo prints or building physical photo albums, you might want to upgrade to a photo printer. When manufacturers optimize printers for pictures, the results can match or exceed that of the best printers available.

Read more
Crutchfield sale: Save on Canon, Sony and Nikon mirrorless cameras
Canon EOS R5

Photography can be a fun and even lucrative endeavor, although it also can be exceedingly expensive, with some of the best full-frame cameras on the market easily reaching and even exceeding one or two thousand dollars, and that's without taking into account the cost of the lenses. Luckily, there is a great sale at Crutchfield right now on various cameras and camera kits, and you can actually grab yourself some excellent cameras, whether you're just starting out or want to upgrade to the next level. To that end, we've picked some of our favorite deals below, although it's well worth checking out the full Crutchfield sale that's happenning now.

What you should buy in Crutchfield's camera sale
If you're just starting out with photography and don't want to spend the thousands of dollars you do for the slightly better cameras that you'll find in the mid-range, the Canon EOS R100 is an excellent option, and this kit includes a lens as well. It has a 24.1-megapixel sensor for high-quality photography, a 3-inch screen so you can get a better sense of what you're filming, and, of course, the RF-S 18-45mm f/4.5-6.3 lens that the kit comes with. It can also connect with both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, and all of that comes packaged at , which is $100 off the usual $599 price tag.

Read more